Issue: Is a law firm that has been disqualified at trial also precluded from handling the appeal of that matter?
| Area of Law: | Ethics & Professional Responsibility, Litigation & Procedure |
| Keywords: | Disqualified law firm; Former client |
| Jurisdiction: | Virgin Islands |
| Cited Cases: | 867 A.2d 70; 639 A.2d 305; 9 F. Supp. 2d 572; 769 F. Supp. 193; 869 F.2d 1565; 566 S.E.2d 560 |
| Cited Statutes: | R.P.C. 1.9 |
| Date: | 07/01/2007 |
As a New Jersey court has pointed out, the language of Rule 1.9 “makes clear that it addresses conflicts created when an attorney represents one client to the detriment of a former client, or uses information gained from prior representation in a subsequent matter to the client’s detriment.” State v. Irizarry, 639 A.2d 305, 314 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 1994). In Irizarry, the court concluded that Rule 1.9 did not apply because “[t]he facts known to the prosecutor/witness concerning defendant’s cooperation are essentially matters of public record, and do not constitute the type of information that R.P.C. 1.9 seeks to protect.” Id. at 341.
The court of appeals employed this reasoning in Johnston v. Harris County Flood Control District, 869 F.2d 1565 (5th Cir. 1989):
This case is analogous [sic] to [the Fifth Circuit case of] Brennan’s, Inc. v. Brennan’s Restaurants, Inc. In Brennan’s, a corporation split into two, competing entities. The attorney for the original corporation chose to work for one of the new entities, severing his ties with the other. When litigation arose between the two new entities, the attorney retained co-counsel. We affirmed the first attorney’s disqualification because of his former relationship with the original corporation. The new co-counsel, however, was not necessarily subject to disqualification for two reasons: there was no previous attorney client relationship between the co-counsel and the original client and the information that the co-counsel learned from the disqualified counsel may not […]
margin-left:1.0in;margin-bottom:.0001pt;text-align:justify’>
