Issue: May parents, as non-owners of a vehicle involved in an accident, ever be liable for the resulting injuries where their son was the driver, under a theory of agency?
| Area of Law: | Personal Injury & Negligence |
| Keywords: | Vicarious liability of parents; Negligent acts of children; Vehicle |
| Jurisdiction: | Vermont |
| Cited Cases: | 160 A.2d 873; 531 A.2d 887; 148 Vt. 180; 75 A. 277; 119 Vt. 40; 117 A.2d 250; 109 A. 911; 554 A.2d 673; 97 Vt. 281; 117 Vt. 525; 160 A. 173; 94 Vt. 211; 104 Vt. 433; 499 A.2d 422 |
| Cited Statutes: | None |
| Date: | 11/01/2007 |
Parents may be liable for a child’s negligence if a factual showing can be made that the parents controlled or directed the use of the vehicle or if the son used the vehicle for the parents’ benefit or interests. Anderson v. Toombs, 119 Vt. 40, 44-45, 117 A.2d 250, 253 (1955) (“‘In order to hold a master liable for the acts of his servant it must appear that the act complained of was done to carry out the directions of the master, express or implied, and not to effect some purpose of the servant alone[.]'” (quoting Gutzwiller v. Am. Tobacco Co., 97 Vt. 281, 284, 122 A. 586, 588)). Whether the child acted as an agent or on his own behalf is a question of fact to be considered by a jury. Ploof v. Putnam, 75 A. 277, 279 (Vt. 1910). In determining the relationship between the child and his parents at the time of the accident, the substance of the relationship must prevail over its form. Piper v. Oakland Motor Co., 94 Vt. 211, 214, 109 A. 911, 911 (1920) (“Whether an agency does in fact exist in a given case depends upon the contract or arrangement under which the business is conducted, and it is entirely immaterial that the parties denominate the arrangement an ‘agency.'”); Bills v. Wardsboro Sch. Dist., 150 Vt. 541, 544, 554 A.2d […]
