Legal Memorandum: Subject of a Notice of Pendency of Action

Issue: What sort of claim may be the subject of a ‘notice of pendency of action’?

Area of Law: Real Estate Law
Keywords: Notice of pendency of action; Subject; Real property claim
Jurisdiction: California
Cited Cases: 9 Cal. App. 3d 397; 265 Cal. App. 2d 131; 118 Cal. App. 3d 571; 75 Cal. App. 4
Cited Statutes: § 405.31
Date: 03/01/2007

It is well-settled California law that a claim that only tangentially involves real property, but does not involve a real property claim is not properly the subject of a notice of pendency of action.  Allied E. Fin. v. Goheen Enters. (1968) 265 Cal. App. 2d 131.

California case law on this issue is sparse, but it is unnecessary to look to case law from jurisdictions across the continent for guidance.  Very recently, a federal district court, construing California’s Notice of Pendency of Action statute, addressed the issue and expunged the lis pendens that had been filed.  Menjivar v. Trophy Props. IV DE, LLC, No. C 06-0386 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 10, 2006).  In Menjivar, the plaintiff was a tenant of an apartment building that had been acquired and was managed by the defendant.  In her suit, the plaintiff alleged, among other things, that the defendant landlord was harassing the plaintiff and trying to force her to leave the rent-controlled building.  She filed a notice of pendency of action, and the defendant moved to expunge.

The Menjivar court first reviewed California’s lis pendens statute, including the legislative intent.  It summarized:  “The principal purpose of the lis pendens statute, therefore, is to protect third parties who might acquire an interest in real property subject to a suit that might affect their interest.”  It acknowledged the lis pendens procedure’s potential for abuse.  Given the potential for abuse, the statute has built-in safeguards, one of which is […]

Scroll to Top